| "The
nice thing (about Tuf-Glide) is that because it dries and
bonds at a molecular level with the metal, it does not
have a flash point, thereby will not catch on fire and
unlikely to cause carbon deposits if used on the motor.
The following
webpage, done by Anthony Arnold, was sent to us. It has
been edited for size. For all of you RC sports car fans
that want to view the full page with graphics and other
great RC sports car information, please visit his website
at:
http://www.aarnold.com/Traxxas/Traxxas_Stampede_projects_hopups_Durability.html
***************************************************************
So you are at
that point where you want to replace that stock motor but
don't want to buy a new ESC on top of buying a new motor.
This is a very low cost upgrade that will not only bump up
the performance and power delivery of a stock Traxxas XL-1
ESC, but will greatly reduce the heat the ESC generates.
This upgrade is also good insurance to take out if you
just want to run a 16T or 17T modified motor on the stock
Taxxas XL-1 ESC, and don't want to have to buy a new ESC.
How much will it improve performance? If you upgrade the
entire electrical path starting from the battery
connection all the way to the motor to 12 gauge wire it
will improve your cars performance about as much as moving
from the stock Tamiya and bullet connector to Deans plugs
or the difference of going from stock bushings to 5x11
bearings in the wheels. Most people approximate either of
these as a 10%-20% improvement. I am continuing to test
how much the XL-1 can actually take and how low a motor
limit it will handle.
One thing I
noticed right away was that the XL-1 really heats up even
with the stock motor and normal driving and really had to
be watched with the 17T Trinity Pro Amber modified motor.
But all this can be fixed easily and cheaply.
A little
electrical resistance 101 lesson - Mechanical friction =
stress on motor = resistance = motor load = heat = more
resistance load = more currant draw = more resistance=
more motor load = more heat...etc. Kind a perpetual
circle. The same goes true for the ESC, the more current
that the ESC has to manage the hotter its going to get.
The idea is to remove or reduce as many of the components
creating resistance on the electronics. Would you rather
push a car an a perfectly flat road or up an off road
trail with lots of big boulders to push the car over.
Looking at this logically, aside from the RPM 5x11 wheel
bearing upgrade, and making sure the motor is lubed, the
gears are not binding and properly lubed, the mechanical
friction elimination part is pretty much taken care of.
For the electrical part, upgrading to a motor like one of
the Trinity Speed Gems with bearings instead of bushings
will reduce resistance at the motor. A good upgrade at
this point is to move completely to Deans connectors
(about $3 per connection point.) The ultra low resistance
Deans connectors will be one of the best overall
electrical upgrades you can make to a stock Stampede and
will make a very noticeable difference in power delivery.
Also sooner or later you will melt the Tamiya plugs anyway
(by the way batteries don't like to be shorted). A 12
gauge wire has about 1/3 the resistance of the stock 14
gauge wires so upgrading to 12 gauge power wires from the
motor with gold or soldered connectors will decrease the
resistance significantly (i.e. heat that the ESC and motor
will generate).
So what about
this XL-1 Electrical upgrade part? I also noticed that the
wire on the ESC were getting warm after a good hard run
even after all the above upgrades (a good indication the
wire gauge is to small for the current draw), so I decided
that I should also upgrade the incoming and outgoing power
wires on the XL-1 ESC to 12 gauge. It may seem like
overkill, but the 12 gauge wire transmits those "get
going quick" current spikes to your motor a lot
better. If you are doing the upgrade and are using 10
gauge wire to your motor, you might as well do it right
and use 12 gauge on the ESC.
The
thermodynamics game: set up some boundaries around a
"system" that separate "system" from
its surroundings, with the following definitions
isolated system
= no exchange of matter or energy with surroundings
closed system =
no exchange of matter but some exchange of energy
open system =
exchange of matter and energy with surroundings
Thermodynamics -
Another part of the upgrade was laying down the ESC in a
more traditional style on a RPM ESC mount. This
accomplished a couple of things - it shortened the wire
runs to the battery and motor, cleaned up those levitating
power switch and receiver power wires, and most
importantly greatly improved air circulation around the
ESC. Heat rises, so by laying down the ESC the heat sinks
naturally allow air to flow through them and up. The stock
orientation creates a heat wall with heat sink fins that
run horizontally and 90 degrees from optimum. I'm sure
design limitations and cost prohibited the heat sinks from
pointing the correct direction, but the stock horizontal
heat sink orientation does not allow for natural airflow
and thereby creates a "thermodynamic closed
system". The new orientation shanges the ESC to a
open system, allows for both forced air cooling (while the
truck is moving) and natural air circulation (i.e. cool
air in and hot air out the top of the fins.)
Final
performance - I noticed a huge decrease in heat generation
on the ESC and coincidently a cooler running motor (I
guess the motor wasn't getting all the juice is needed
either.) Even at it's worst with 15/87 gearing and a
Trinity 17T Pro Amber motor, the ESC was at worst warm.
Although I didn't do any lab testing, the old
"eyeball Dyno" looked like about a 15%-20%
increase in get up and go on from the ESC after the
upgrade. The difference was really noticeable after about
5 minutes or at the point the stock ESC and motor would be
really hot (remember the hotter the electronics, the more
resistance and less efficient everything is.) In the end,
I think I spent $10.00 on 1 ft. each black and red 10
gauge power wire and some extra Deans connectors. Although
it doesn't convert the XL-1 into a Novac Super Rooster,
the conversion does add a lot of durability and make the
the stock ESC a much better performer.
The How To -
Traxxas XL-1 ESC Electrical Upgrade
Its pretty
simple just go slow. Note that you do need to have some
soldering experience. It should go without saying, but
make sure you let everything cool down in between
soldering steps and care should be taken not to overheat
and de-solder the other components on the ESC circuit
board.
First disconnect
everything from the ESC and remove it from the truck.
Unscrew the two
screws holding on the heat sinks and and remove the heat
sinks. Unscrew the four screws on the back of the ESC and
remove the cover.
CAREFULLY remove
the ESC guts from the shell.
De-solder and
remove both the positive/red power wires.
Re-gauge the ESC
end of the 10 gauge leads to 14 gauge as shown and then
tin the wires. If you tin the wire end properly and seat
the "stepped" lead fully into the ESC board as
shown, this will be a very strong low-resistance
connection.
Prepare and tin
your +/- power leads and terminate with Deans plugs. (it
can be tough to solder the plugs after you have soldered
everything up to the ESC, so it good to get the Deans
plugs installed first.) Slide on the shrink warp and
shrink to cover the exposed wire and plug pin.
Carefully heat
the inner power hole on the board with the tip of the
soldering iron and slide in and seat the appropriate power
wire. Once the wire is seated, heat the tip of the wire
sticking through the other side of the ESC circuit board
to solder the wire in place. You should have enough
residual solder from tinning the wire end and the solder
left on the board that do additional solder should be
needed.
Repeat with the
the other power wire.
Now remove the
negative/black power wires and run through the above steps
and get them soldered in place.
Re-route the
thinner BEC and power switch wires in between the
positive. These should be at the bottom of the "wire
pile" closest to the circuit board.
Trim about 2mm
off the crescent shaped wire holder off the the back
cover.
Extend the top
cover wire inset by about 1/8" or as needed, just to
the point that all the wires are snuggly held in place.
Trim off the ESC
side mounting tabs.
Re-assemble.
Cover the
setting/tuning holes with black electrical tape to seal
out dust and moisture.
Mount with
double stick tape or Velcro. I use the "heavy duty
Velcro", it has no positive and negative stripes.
This Velcro is made of all hard plastic interlocking balls
and is much cleaner and tougher.
Done - You now
have a cooler running ESC with a lot less resistance and
about a 15%-20% performance increase.
Testing Criteria
and Warnings for the Upgraded XL-1
I have spent the
better part of a month moving from a very conservative
13/87 gearing to and 18/87 gearing again using the Amber
17T motor. The 18/87 gearing using a 17T motor is about
the limit for my testing for this phase, it runs about as
hot as is did in completely stock ESC/motor configuration
during my testing. That said, I think the ESC has
demonstrated the ability to handle enough stress for me to
test a 15T, 16T, or maybe a P94 16T. My hope is that I
will be able to dependably and cool-ly run a 15T motor –
we’ll see.
Warning – Don’t
just pop a 17T with 18/87 gearing in your car, I'm not
going to listen to you bitch after you blow your ESC. I am
using a very methodical controlled testing process and
have very very slowly moved up to that gearing over a
period of a month or so. If you run the car slow or use it
to rock climb at that gearing, you will probably blow the
ESC.
Max recommended
gearing - You should have no overheating problems (after
the XL-1 upgrade) when geared from 13/87 –16/87 with the
Trinity 17T pro Amber.
Goals - My goals
in this experiment were to primarily define the stress
limit of the XL-1 after going through the electrical and
orientation/cooling upgrade on the ESC. Secondly, develop
a low cost/no cost method for everyone out there stuck
with XL-1's to safely run hotter motors such as the
Trinity 17T Pro Amber.
Testing
criteria:
Gearing: From
13/87 – 18/87 (6.69 – 4.83)
Body: Attached
– stock position.
Ambient Temp:
30-50 Degrees F
Runs/Time: 2 at
about 10-15 Min. each
Batteries:
6-Cell 3000Mh
Track: Urban -
50% Road – 30% Lawn – 20% Rock (landscaping)
Throttle
Control: Top 50% of throttle range
Braking: Hard
and controlled braking.
ESC: XL-1
Modified See Above
Other: All power
wires upgrade to 12 gauge wire
RPM Bearing
carrier and bearing upgrade
All power
connectors upgraded to Deans Plugs
The final review
and post for the Project Stampede upgraded XL-1 ESC
Sadly, the
upgraded XL-1 time’s came after I got a little cocky and
did not properly winterize my upgraded Project Stampede
XL-1 ESC before going out in some really wet slushy snow
in Omaha’s one again –off again weather patterns. Yep,
you bet I fried that sucker like a well-done piece of
bacon, but I was able to complete my testing before it’s
untimely demise.
As you will see
in the above posts, I did some upgrades to the stock
Traxxas XL-1 ESC to see if it could safely handle the more
extreme modified motors without melting down.
It can and it
will do it very well. First let me lay down this warning
– “Although I was able to run the Xl-1 with a both a
17T Trinity Pro Amber and a 15T Trinity Titanite motor
without blowing anything up. I only recommend going with
the 17T Pro Amber and only if the upgrade is completed”
The reason is that when running the 15T motor the upgraded
Project Stampede ESC runs at about it’s stock hot
temperature and I really think this is too hot to expect
any really long-term durability. Using the 15T is
definitely not something you want to do a lot of very slow
maneuvering with as the ESC is very close to it’s limit
with a 15T motor.
The 15T motor
was geared up to 13/87 with no adverse effects during
higher speed maneuvering (no rock crawling). However, I
very carefully worked up to this gearing starting at 12/90
with initial testing only on the road at full throttle
(the easiest on the ESC).
So there you
have it, I have sacrificed my XL-1 for the sake of
experimentation and for the enjoyment and education of
all.
Good Luck!
RPM Wide Bumper
- (REQUIRED ITEM) What ever model you chose MSC or ESC,
buy the freaking $5 RPM wide bumper. The RPM bumper will
save you a lot of money. Even in stock form the Stampede
is a little faster than you would think and despite your
best efforts you WILL hammer the front of the Stampede
into poles, the garage, the curb, the wall, your friends,
your car,...your get the idea. When this happens without
that huge RPM bumper you could crack or break the body,
the front shock tower, camber links, stripe servo
gears,... again you get the picture. A very wise
investment indeed that will pay for itself over and over.
While you are at it also pick up some of the shock spring
retainers, they will not break like the stock ones.
Traxxas Aluminum
Shock Caps for Rustler/Stampede - Everyone says the stock
plastic ones pop off and blow silicon shock oil every
where (you don't want to have to clean this stuff up),
having swapped them out the the aluminum versions before
even a first run, I have never had a problem. (See Mis-Behaving-RC
in Useful Links for the how to). Note pick up a roll of
Teflon tape form the hardware store and some Trinity Buggy
Blast and some 50wt Silicon Oil from your hobby shop while
you are at it. If you follow the directions on Mis-behaving-RC
you will have a shock almost as strong as aluminum model
at far less the price. You will thank me for telling you
this the first 2-3 foot jump the Stampede makes
un-eventfully. From a long term perspective, I see no
reason for me upgrade to better shock, the rebuild takes
the best plastic shock in the industry and makes it handle
anything I've been able to throw at it.
RPM Gear Cover
for Rustler/Stampede - The reason for this upgrade is that
the stock gear cover leaves this small gap near the axel
and allows debris to get into the gear box., The $5 RPM
gear cover one provides complete coverage. If you are all
about color, your can get the RPM cover in a rainbow of
colors. The first time you pull a small twig or leaf into
your gear box and shred a spur gear you will wish you had
bought one.
Floppy Antenna
Fix - After flipping your Stampede a couple of times you
will start to notice that the extra 2-4" of antenna
wire flopping around and hanging out of the antenna rod is
taking quite a beating. Sooner or later if you don't
secure it it will get ground off and you will have to
replace your antenna. One easy fix is to spiral it down
the rod and use a piece of electrical heat shrink to
secure it and top it off back off with the rubber antenna
cap.
Lubrication Made
Easy - I have been trying different lubricants (keep you
mind out of the gutter), with the purpose of finding
better motor and chassis lubes that 3N1 oil. Here is what
I have found so far.
Chassis - I
really like are Sentry Solutions Tuff-Glide. The
Sentry Solutions was developed for the Navy Seal teams
firearms and equipment. The nice thing is that because it
dries and bonds at a molecular level with the metal, it
does not have a flash point, thereby will not catch on
fire and unlikely to cause carbon deposits if used on the
motor.
Motor - The best
thing I have found is Turbine oil. I found it at Ace
hardware next to the 3N1 oil. Again its wax based, and is
actually designed specifically for electrical motors,
bushing, and bearings, and is designed for high heat
environments. The best part its $2. Oddly enough it does
not have a name at all, I could find on it was ZipSpout.
Clear container with weird looking spout.
How to replace
the stock cheap servo gears when your break them. - Sooner
or later you will hammer the gears in the stock servo
enough that they will eventually fail. The optimum
solution is to buy a new super durable metal gear high
torque servo like a $55 Hitec -5625MG (metal gears, high
torque, watertight and dustproof). That said, the $4 bag
of replacement gears will probably be your next best
option instead of picking up lesser quality servo. No
hobby shop I have every been to carries Traxxas servo
replacement gears, but as luck would have it, the Futaba
FS-3003 replacement gears, available just about anywhere,
are direct replacements for the stock Stampede servo
gears. The only gear in the bag that is not a direct fit
is the black gear, so in the unlikely event that you
manage to stripe the larger gear on the servo you may want
to consider a new servo. When you make the replacement,
replace all the gears (expect the large one mentioned
earlier) and toss the old ones. Chances are even if you
can't see anything wrong with the gears, you may have a
slightly bent tooth that will cause another trip to the
hobby store. Make sure you clean the gear box cavity well
to assure that no chipped gear teeth could cause future
problems. Re-assemble all the gears and pack the cavity
with white lithium or silicon grease (increases
lubrication and waterproofing) and re-install the servo.
Heavy Duty Metal
Gear Servo- The optimum servo solution is to buy a new
super durable metal gear high torque servo like a $55
Hitec -5625MG (metal gears, high torque, watertight and
dustproof). See MisBehavin-RC.com in the links are for his
comprehensive overview of servos.
Nitor Rustler
Front Shock Tower - A little modification I have been
intending to do. Buy the Traxxas #4439 Nitro Rustler Front
Shock Tower and required only a modification. This think
is nearly as tough as my Lexan version below and is
currently what I am running. Great deal if your can find
one.
Lexan Front
Shock Tower - Ok, so I got tired of replacing the front
shock tower. It never gave out completely as long as the
front body post holder was mounted, but I found it would
crack from once incident or another every other month or
so.
As you all may
know a router can do some pretty amazing things. However I
needed one the other day and realized that I gave all my
less used tools to my father during our last house move.
So I was
cruising the local hardware store and picked up $20 simple
router attachment for the Dremel tool and a couple cutter
and mini-router bits to see how it worked on Lexan. Holly
cow (G-rating), you can do some amazing milling and
routing with this set-up. It has depth adjustment
settings... yep you can mill your own custom battery tray
in Lexan. ( I did it and it looks good.)
Along with some
chassis configurations, I went nuts on a sheet of Lexan
and made a couple front shock towers. Not a quite project,
but pretty easy tracing and cutting project. If you are
interested in making pieces out of Lexan, this is a pretty
cheap way to go.
What I came up
with was this:
I used 1/4"
gray Lexan and simply traced the shape of the original
shock tower but left the top connected with a 1/4"
stripe. This worked alot better than a screw on brace
because it provides a lot of side to side strength and
obviously the Lexan is much stronger than the stock
plastic tower. There is obviously a performance advantage
in that the shock tower now is much more rigid, but I did
this because I hate replacing parts more than once. To
mount the shocks I used some of the spare shock parts that
came with the Traxxas. I used a 3 hole shock plunger for a
spacer, a stepped shock mounting piece, and a double worm
bolt. I later, went to the slightly lighter Rustler Nitro
shock tower and haven't had a problem.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Skid Plate -
Wheelie Bar on the Cheap
Get a piece of
ABS Plastic from the hobby shop.
Cut to width.
Use the brace as a template and make the counter sunk
holes in the plastic. Bolt it to the chassis using the
existing stock screws.
Use a torch
carefully to make the bends in the plastic to mold around
the chassis. The back potion of the plate I folds over and
is doubled for strength and folds back to just under the
tranny housing. I made it just long enough so that it acts
as not only as a wheelie bar but also a springy rear
bumper (which I need). I was actually attempting to fit a
RPM front bumper on the back when I engineered this
instead. It has worked great and has taken a real beating
and has saved I am sure countless part replacements.
Another side
benefit has been that it works great in the taller grass,
and fields where there are lots of tings for the x brace
to hang or get caught on. It also adds "some"
floatation during snow outings, but not enough to actually
support the Pede.
I later cut off
the very rear portion of the plate and removed the second
layer (really un-needed) and bolted on the stock front
bumper for a less ghetto and more finished look. Also
added an extra margin of protection.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Front and Rear
Shock Tower Braces
This was a
pretty funny innovation. I was seeing what I could do with
all the left over turnbuckles in my toolbox. I put it up
to the shocks and called myself a genius. I never liked
the way those shocks hung out there on the mounting posts
without additional support. In fact most of the breakages
I saw and have seem on other Stampedes and Rustlers are
due to weakness in this area.
An easy way to
significantly strengthen up the front shock tower is to
add thse Project Stampede Exclusive Shock Tower Braces.
Although this was part of my Ultra-Pede conversion, this
is something I should have done much earlier and recommend
to everyone. I was going through shock towers like crazy
until I moved over to the Nitro Shock tower, however this
has strengthened it even more.
This is
basically a cut down 54mm Traxxas Turnbuckles previously
used for the Front camber links #1937 and reused rod ends.
Also need either grub screws or longer bolts. The Rear
turnbuckles is my old steering tie rod (I think) left from
the front end after the Ultra-Pede conversion.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dual Front
Camber Links
Part of Project
Stampede Ultra-Pede Build - See this
Another
accidental innovation.
Originally, I
installed the double sided pivot balls because, I thought
it would make things a lot more flexible in the long run.
You could mount/position the camber however you wanted on
the fly and could have multiple preset camber lengths to
snap on for different camber and suspension set ups.
Also I thought
for testing it would make things easier without tearing
apart the front end just to move the placement of the
camber link placement from the front to rear mount. I
though the dual cambers would be cool looking and fun to
post for everyone enjoyment, but I never really intended
to leave them on. After using this set up, they are not
coming off - they are a permanent addition to the Ultra-Pede,
it is insanely solid and durable.
What's really
sick is that I can also use dual Jato Camber links like
the single one I am running on the rear.
I tried the Dual
Jato's but though that was complete and utter overkill.
You look at that
setup and think, that's overkill. But then you get it
installed and notice immediately the torquing at the
attachment of the caster block and the shock tower has
been eliminated. Also you are not able to wiggle the
caster at all and is as solid as the attachment at the
A-Arm. Running the camber links more equally distributed
the load on both sides of the caster blocks and shock
tower and should greatly reduce the probably of damage to
the front suspension.
All of a sudden
you really start to think that it should have been that
way to begin with to handle what we are subjecting our
Pede's to. In the end dual camber links are still
overkill, I ended up going with single Jato camber links
all around that I have been all but completely happy with.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Traxxas Jato
Turnbuckles on Rear and Front for Camber Links
A direct fit are
the Traxxas Jato Camber links turnbuckles 58mm #5539 -
also a direct fit for front camber links on the Stampede
after the wide-pede conversion. You will need some of the
Traxxas Shim Set Jato balls #5529 and replace all the
shorter balls with these longer balls to provide the
clearance required on the front. Don't think I am going to
bust these.
Make sure you
use the captured ball ends and Traxxas washer machine head
screws otherwise there will be to much play if you use the
stock shoulder bolts.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Motor Heat Sink
- Associated Motor Heat Sink TC4 #31048
This was more of
an adventure than simply snapping the thing on the motor
can.
First off, as
expected and stated on Misbehavin-Rc's site, the
transmission housing requires modification (i.e. removal
of some of the motor housing. This was no big deal, grab
the Dremel with a cut off bit and make three linear cuts -
done.
Second, the heat
sink doesn't fit with the lower fins so those needed to be
removed, more grinding with the Dremel.
Third and
possibly the most frustrating part of the project was
locating and positioning the heatsink so that the motor
could be bolted up on the motor plate. The stickers needed
to be removed from the can (the can has a permanent mark
indicating 0 for timing), and sliding the heatsink on to
the shaft end. What I finally ended up doing was
installing the motor as normal without the heatsink and
then marking which fin lined up with the timing mark and
then removed the motor, attached the heat sink and then
re-installed the motor.
The heatsink
works great, I have yet to hit the 5 second touch test
limit and the motor runs much much cooler. Would I do the
project again? In a heartbeat, however I would recommend
buying a Integy heatsink such as the one pictured without
lower heat fins or one of their fan assisted models (see
note below.) I think in reality if you are gearing
everything correctly you really don't need a heatsink,
however everyone always overgears and/or does some high
stress bashing with stock gearing when it should be geared
even lower, so in my opinion this optional accessory give
you motor some extra stay cool insurance.
Long-Term
Update: I definitely would not go for the fan assisted
model on an off road vehicle. These is just way too much
junk that ends up in the fins. I have been exceptionally
happy with the heat sink and have yet to get the motor to
it's previous flesh searing temps.
|